New York New York Pizza
3757 Bruce B Downs Blvd, Wesley Chapel, FL, 33544
New York New York Pizza Menu
Sorry, We are updating this restaurant menu details.
Visit below restaurant in Wesley Chapel for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Wesley Chapel for healthy meals suggestion.
Visit below restaurant in Wesley Chapel for healthy meals suggestion.
Sorry, we don't have Q&A for this restaurant.
Sorry, No Coupons available for this restaurant.
-
Address :
3757 Bruce B Downs Blvd
Wesley Chapel, FL, 33544 - Phone (813) 528-8771
- Website https://nynypizzeria.com
- Click To Get Directions
Opening Hours
- Mon :11:00 am - 10
- Mon : 11:00 am - 10
Specialities
- Takes Reservations : No
Delivery : Yes
Take-out : Yes
Accepts Credit Cards : Yes
Good For : Lunch
Parking : Private Lot
Bike Parking : Yes
Good for Kids : Yes
Good for Groups : Yes
Attire : Casual
Ambience : Casual
Noise Level : Average
Alcohol : No
Outdoor Seating : Yes
Wi-Fi : Free
Has TV : Yes
Waiter Service : Yes
Caters : Yes
Categories
Pizza
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
WE SERVE THE FOLLOWING STATES
Looky Weed - Buy Marijuana Online
Looky Weed is here to help you navigate the maze of legalized marijuana. We provide you with a complete dispensary directory.
Scott K.
It is a good thing it was not our first visit to this pizzeria. Pizza was over cooked, and the wings were over cooked and dry. This is the second experience that was less than we expected. This used to be my favorite and go-to pizzeria, but it looks like we will be moving on...
(2)Danielle M.
Pizza was great. Crispy and greasy with a yummy sauce. Garlic knots were dripping in garlic. The 6 inch Italian sub was the size of a footlong! Customer service was great. Expansive menu. They also deliver really far away. Will definitely be back to try the pastas.
(5)Angela A.
So I need to update my review. I believe my previous review was based on an off night for the restaurant. NY NY pizza contacted me and asked me to give them a second chance. They sent me a gift certificate for a free pizza and we decided to give it a go. The service was completely different than our first visit. They greeted us and were so friendly and helpful. We ordered calamari for an appetizer and I was pleasantly surprised. It was piping hot and not rubbery. We ordered an x-large pie with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, onions and artichokes and it was delicious. The pizza was hot and perfectly cooked. The crust was crisp and had a great flavor and happily it was not greasy in the least. We took home leftovers and it was even delicious the next day. We were very satisfied and may make this our new local pizza joint. I was especially surprised by how eager Clarance was to make sure we had a good experience. He sent me a message right away and even took time to follow up, to make sure our experience was a good one. That's impressive. I wasn't even sure that anyone read these reviews, beyond other reviewers I appreciate that kind of consideration. I would also like to mention that the young man that served us and took our order was extremely friendly and we even shared a few jokes. I wish I had asked his name, but he made our dinner quite enjoyable. Thanks NY NY Pizza for caring enough to convince me to give it another chance. I'm glad you did.
(4)Samantha M.
I would rate a 2 star off our first time ordering and a 3 off the second time. Their sauce is good, but the pizza is nothing to scream over...it may because we got delivery but the pizza came kind of flappy which is not cool. And we had $13 and change for our order and decided to tell us right before we hung up that we had to order something else b/c they wouldn't deliver to us for any less than $15. I offered to give extra tip to the driver and they refused. I worked at a pizza place back in high school and we would never argue over a $1 and change...especially if they offered to give extra tip to the driver. Anyway, I wish Pizza Mania delivered but for now we'll just continue to pick up or dine in there.
(2)Dava M.
Last night I was craving for a good hand made brick oven pizza, I found this pizzeria and it was just what I was craving for! Great and fresh ingredients, rich flavor. It was perfect. I totally recommend this pizzeria!!!
(5)Krista A.
Great pizza. The only reason I'm not giving it 5 stars is because my husband didn't like it as much. It has thin crust and a nice sweet sauce.
(4)Eddie R.
Great tasting pizza! Not the best I have had, but definitely good for the area. They messed up my order once, and once I called them back and brought the pizza back (since it was carry-out) they replaced it with the correct one and included some garlic knots for free. I would recommend them if you want good pizza!
(4)Savannah L.
Ordered a pepperoni and cheese pizza for delivery and was totally not impressed. It was so greasy that by the time it was finally delivered it was floppy and not very appetizing to look at. It tasted good and the cheese sticks were average, but that's about all it had going for it. The customer service was horrible. When I called the place my order the person who answered was impatient and borderline rude. I understand she is probably a high school kid with a summer job, but having no patience for someone trying to order while dealing with a 4 year old made the experience very unpleasant. Also when I thought last minute about adding a drink she was not very polite about informing me she had already closed out my tab and would have to pay by cash. Obviously I declined. I was told it would take 20 to 30 min for my pizza to be delivered, at 45 minutes it still hadn't arrived. With semi politeness I was told my pizza left a while ago and should be there momentarily and if not to call back in another 10 to 15 min. My pizza finally arrived another 6 minutes later. I will say the delivery guy was polite though never apologizing for the wait, making me question when my order actually went out. I probably will not be eating from here again when I babysit.
(3)Lavina S.
This is one of the best pizza places I've been to outside of NY!! Being a native New Yorker expectations are really high, but NY Pizza delivered! The pizza variety and quality were excellent; the staff and establishment were greats too! If you're looking for a taste of home or just want some good pizza give NY pizza a call! I had the plain cheese and the florentine and they were both excellent, with prices that are reasonable too!
(4)Ali P.
Ordered pizza for pick up from here last week. Pizza was good and food was ready on time. Just a warning, they go a little heavy on the garlic. All in all very good experience and we will be ordering from them again.
(4)Raina R.
Ordered delivery & was quicker than expected!! NY NY Supreme was great, nice thin crust but not crispy except the edges (probably due to delivery sitting out) but was still really yummy. Huge slices & not greasy at all!!
(4)Michael B.
Normally, the pizza is very good...but, the pizza I ordered and had delivered was, by far, the worst I have had from this place. Cold, soggy-terrible. If I order again I will go in and pick it up!
(1)Melissa M.
Very good pizza crust and classic marinara. I also like that they have a great menu of specialty pizzas. We got the Mayor Giuliani: pesto sauce, tomato, pepperocini, ricotta. We had sausage added to it - so good! The kids had classic pepperoni which they loved. They delivered to us - showed up hot and fresh and we're a few miles away. We will be trying more from NY, NY!
(5)Rachel M.
We tried their chicken wings and Stromboli, and thought they were very tasty. The Stromboli which is like a calzone but no ricotta cheese, and you are able to pick three toppings for 7.95 seemed to be the most cost effective, and a huge size. The chicken wings were flavorfull and they had a few options sauce wise to pick. There is about 4 tables inside, and about 3 or 4 tables with umbrellas outside. We really liked our food here. This place seems pretty brand new and down the street from the Florida Hospital Wesley Chapel, and Close to Seven Oaks neighborhood, but with all the trees, it is pretty easy to miss, so make sure to keep an eye out for it. They also have sandwiches, pastas, and other salads and appetizers.
(4)Diana S.
Pizza was true new York pizza.calamrie was cooked perfect. I think we came on a day that some one didn't show up for work,so we had a a little wait. Other then that it was perfecto
(4)Beth K.
This was really good pizza at pretty decent price. The crust was crispy and delicious. I got the Florentine white pizza and was really happy with it. The menu says "small or personal" but it could really feed 3 people. I also got the garlic knots and wouldn't recommend those if you will be in contact with or in the general vicinity of anybody that has a nose. They are crazy garlicky! I am not one to shy away from garlic but this was even too much for me.
(4)Michele L.
I don't recommend this place for catering. I ordered a FULL tray of eggplant parm and a FULL tray of chicken parm for my daughters birthday party. Each tray was $75.00. I was VERY angry when I saw that the whole freakin tray was mostly pasta. There was a thin layer off eggplant and the rest was all pasta. Same goes for the chicken parm. I went into the restaurant to talk to the manager and he didn't do anything to resolve the situation at all. He said that this was all explained to us. He wasn't even there when the order was taken. Nothing was explained to us. If I knew that I was going to be paying close to $200 for pasta that I could of just paid for 89 cents a box I would NEVER have ordered here. This place is very misleading. I will make sure to tell the few people I know who were thinking about ordering here for their parties to not waste their time and money. Don't waste your time at this place...
(1)Eric G.
Pretty good example of new your style pizza. Definitely will be returning. The crust is the perfect crispy yet soft thin crust that you can easily cut with a fork. The cheese was greasy and had a very nice oven toasted top that I rarely find. Not too much sauce and even reheated very well. I'm not a pizza snob but I don't want to give 5 stars only having been there once. I'll have to try a specialty pizza and something else and I'll let you know if this is a 5 star worthy joint.
(4)Dan S.
Excellent service and great food. The staff is warm and friendly. On my way out the door I dropped my food on the floor and no questions asked, the cook came over, picked it up, and replaced it at no cost. Good people work here and the pizza is delicious!
(5)Kevin S.
Love the Ybor store, live in Wesley Chapel, gave them a try tonight...amazing! So glad they have one closer to home, great pizza!!
(5)Bruce G.
Tried the Ybor New York New York many times. Defiantly the best delivery pizza in wesley chapel...
(5)Stephanie P.
Delicious New York Style pizza! Also their cheese steaks are incredible too!
(5)Gail L.
Had to try the new place in town. Clean dining room and pleasant staff. Pizza was good but not great. Crust was a bit soggy but I think that is our fault for ordering double mushrooms. We will be back to try their many menu options but I think we will stick with Marcos when it is time for pizza.
(3)Will W.
The newest pizza place in town. So very worth the visit. Everything we have tried on the menu is fantastic. Hand made items made to order in authentic NY style perfection. If you find yourself in lovely, sunny Wesley Chapel but crave the tase from the NYC beat feet to NY NY Pizza!
(5)Kevin H.
Never been to NYC but in WC this is the best I've had. Trust me, my sons favorite food is pizza and he has eaten more than I care to admit, which means so have I. Problem is most of what I have tasted in this area is fair at best. Sure it's okay for the growing teenagers palette, and most of it he likes ok, but its still just "KIDS" pizza, meant to fill their guts. I, on the other hand have not tasted really good pizza in WC until eating here. The crust is the perfect thickness with just the right amount of chew. Sauce is balanced and well flavored. The cheese is a beautiful molten blanket of rich, nutty, dairy comfort. Toppings were good quality real food. The staff there have always been friendly and the place is always clean. This is pizza for anyone who demands more from their pizza than just a gut filler. This is real pizza for real men!!
(4)Laura-Lee H.
We moved from NY a few months ago and were worried about finding good pizza down here. We love this place! The pizza is some of the best I've ever had, not just for FL. We have also had a few different pasta dishes and it was all really good! My favorite was the chicken francese. They provide garlic bread with it, too!
(5)Connie H.
owner attitude not great ordered a pizza got it home it was not good it was one of the pizzas they have on display for slices it was late and they obviously didnt want to make a pizza so they heated up one that was already made pizza tasted reheated this may have been an isolated incident but called to complain,owner had no apology but argued with me instead care less even argued with me for complaining I will not patronize this establishment getting good food is not just about taste and quality it is also based on loyalty to the customer DO NOT PATRONIZE THIS establishment if the owner is like that they r probably allowing them to TAMPER with your FOOD he lost a loyal customer
(1)Angela A.
So I need to update my review. I believe my previous review was based on an off night for the restaurant. NY NY pizza contacted me and asked me to give them a second chance. They sent me a gift certificate for a free pizza and we decided to give it a go. The service was completely different than our first visit. They greeted us and were so friendly and helpful. We ordered calamari for an appetizer and I was pleasantly surprised. It was piping hot and not rubbery. We ordered an x-large pie with pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, onions and artichokes and it was delicious. The pizza was hot and perfectly cooked. The crust was crisp and had a great flavor and happily it was not greasy in the least. We took home leftovers and it was even delicious the next day. We were very satisfied and may make this our new local pizza joint. I was especially surprised by how eager Clarance was to make sure we had a good experience. He sent me a message right away and even took time to follow up, to make sure our experience was a good one. That's impressive. I wasn't even sure that anyone read these reviews, beyond other reviewers I appreciate that kind of consideration. I would also like to mention that the young man that served us and took our order was extremely friendly and we even shared a few jokes. I wish I had asked his name, but he made our dinner quite enjoyable. Thanks NY NY Pizza for caring enough to convince me to give it another chance. I'm glad you did.
(4)Samantha M.
I would rate a 2 star off our first time ordering and a 3 off the second time. Their sauce is good, but the pizza is nothing to scream over...it may because we got delivery but the pizza came kind of flappy which is not cool. And we had $13 and change for our order and decided to tell us right before we hung up that we had to order something else b/c they wouldn't deliver to us for any less than $15. I offered to give extra tip to the driver and they refused. I worked at a pizza place back in high school and we would never argue over a $1 and change...especially if they offered to give extra tip to the driver. Anyway, I wish Pizza Mania delivered but for now we'll just continue to pick up or dine in there.
(2)Dava M.
Last night I was craving for a good hand made brick oven pizza, I found this pizzeria and it was just what I was craving for! Great and fresh ingredients, rich flavor. It was perfect. I totally recommend this pizzeria!!!
(5)Krista A.
Great pizza. The only reason I'm not giving it 5 stars is because my husband didn't like it as much. It has thin crust and a nice sweet sauce.
(4)Eddie R.
Great tasting pizza! Not the best I have had, but definitely good for the area. They messed up my order once, and once I called them back and brought the pizza back (since it was carry-out) they replaced it with the correct one and included some garlic knots for free. I would recommend them if you want good pizza!
(4)Scott K.
It is a good thing it was not our first visit to this pizzeria. Pizza was over cooked, and the wings were over cooked and dry. This is the second experience that was less than we expected. This used to be my favorite and go-to pizzeria, but it looks like we will be moving on...
(2)Danielle M.
Pizza was great. Crispy and greasy with a yummy sauce. Garlic knots were dripping in garlic. The 6 inch Italian sub was the size of a footlong! Customer service was great. Expansive menu. They also deliver really far away. Will definitely be back to try the pastas.
(5)Savannah L.
Ordered a pepperoni and cheese pizza for delivery and was totally not impressed. It was so greasy that by the time it was finally delivered it was floppy and not very appetizing to look at. It tasted good and the cheese sticks were average, but that's about all it had going for it. The customer service was horrible. When I called the place my order the person who answered was impatient and borderline rude. I understand she is probably a high school kid with a summer job, but having no patience for someone trying to order while dealing with a 4 year old made the experience very unpleasant. Also when I thought last minute about adding a drink she was not very polite about informing me she had already closed out my tab and would have to pay by cash. Obviously I declined. I was told it would take 20 to 30 min for my pizza to be delivered, at 45 minutes it still hadn't arrived. With semi politeness I was told my pizza left a while ago and should be there momentarily and if not to call back in another 10 to 15 min. My pizza finally arrived another 6 minutes later. I will say the delivery guy was polite though never apologizing for the wait, making me question when my order actually went out. I probably will not be eating from here again when I babysit.
(3)Lavina S.
This is one of the best pizza places I've been to outside of NY!! Being a native New Yorker expectations are really high, but NY Pizza delivered! The pizza variety and quality were excellent; the staff and establishment were greats too! If you're looking for a taste of home or just want some good pizza give NY pizza a call! I had the plain cheese and the florentine and they were both excellent, with prices that are reasonable too!
(4)Ali P.
Ordered pizza for pick up from here last week. Pizza was good and food was ready on time. Just a warning, they go a little heavy on the garlic. All in all very good experience and we will be ordering from them again.
(4)Raina R.
Ordered delivery & was quicker than expected!! NY NY Supreme was great, nice thin crust but not crispy except the edges (probably due to delivery sitting out) but was still really yummy. Huge slices & not greasy at all!!
(4)Michael B.
Normally, the pizza is very good...but, the pizza I ordered and had delivered was, by far, the worst I have had from this place. Cold, soggy-terrible. If I order again I will go in and pick it up!
(1)Melissa M.
Very good pizza crust and classic marinara. I also like that they have a great menu of specialty pizzas. We got the Mayor Giuliani: pesto sauce, tomato, pepperocini, ricotta. We had sausage added to it - so good! The kids had classic pepperoni which they loved. They delivered to us - showed up hot and fresh and we're a few miles away. We will be trying more from NY, NY!
(5)Rachel M.
We tried their chicken wings and Stromboli, and thought they were very tasty. The Stromboli which is like a calzone but no ricotta cheese, and you are able to pick three toppings for 7.95 seemed to be the most cost effective, and a huge size. The chicken wings were flavorfull and they had a few options sauce wise to pick. There is about 4 tables inside, and about 3 or 4 tables with umbrellas outside. We really liked our food here. This place seems pretty brand new and down the street from the Florida Hospital Wesley Chapel, and Close to Seven Oaks neighborhood, but with all the trees, it is pretty easy to miss, so make sure to keep an eye out for it. They also have sandwiches, pastas, and other salads and appetizers.
(4)Diana S.
Pizza was true new York pizza.calamrie was cooked perfect. I think we came on a day that some one didn't show up for work,so we had a a little wait. Other then that it was perfecto
(4)Beth K.
This was really good pizza at pretty decent price. The crust was crispy and delicious. I got the Florentine white pizza and was really happy with it. The menu says "small or personal" but it could really feed 3 people. I also got the garlic knots and wouldn't recommend those if you will be in contact with or in the general vicinity of anybody that has a nose. They are crazy garlicky! I am not one to shy away from garlic but this was even too much for me.
(4)Laura-Lee H.
We moved from NY a few months ago and were worried about finding good pizza down here. We love this place! The pizza is some of the best I've ever had, not just for FL. We have also had a few different pasta dishes and it was all really good! My favorite was the chicken francese. They provide garlic bread with it, too!
(5)Kevin H.
Never been to NYC but in WC this is the best I've had. Trust me, my sons favorite food is pizza and he has eaten more than I care to admit, which means so have I. Problem is most of what I have tasted in this area is fair at best. Sure it's okay for the growing teenagers palette, and most of it he likes ok, but its still just "KIDS" pizza, meant to fill their guts. I, on the other hand have not tasted really good pizza in WC until eating here. The crust is the perfect thickness with just the right amount of chew. Sauce is balanced and well flavored. The cheese is a beautiful molten blanket of rich, nutty, dairy comfort. Toppings were good quality real food. The staff there have always been friendly and the place is always clean. This is pizza for anyone who demands more from their pizza than just a gut filler. This is real pizza for real men!!
(4)Connie H.
owner attitude not great ordered a pizza got it home it was not good it was one of the pizzas they have on display for slices it was late and they obviously didnt want to make a pizza so they heated up one that was already made pizza tasted reheated this may have been an isolated incident but called to complain,owner had no apology but argued with me instead care less even argued with me for complaining I will not patronize this establishment getting good food is not just about taste and quality it is also based on loyalty to the customer DO NOT PATRONIZE THIS establishment if the owner is like that they r probably allowing them to TAMPER with your FOOD he lost a loyal customer
(1)Michele L.
I don't recommend this place for catering. I ordered a FULL tray of eggplant parm and a FULL tray of chicken parm for my daughters birthday party. Each tray was $75.00. I was VERY angry when I saw that the whole freakin tray was mostly pasta. There was a thin layer off eggplant and the rest was all pasta. Same goes for the chicken parm. I went into the restaurant to talk to the manager and he didn't do anything to resolve the situation at all. He said that this was all explained to us. He wasn't even there when the order was taken. Nothing was explained to us. If I knew that I was going to be paying close to $200 for pasta that I could of just paid for 89 cents a box I would NEVER have ordered here. This place is very misleading. I will make sure to tell the few people I know who were thinking about ordering here for their parties to not waste their time and money. Don't waste your time at this place...
(1)Eric G.
Pretty good example of new your style pizza. Definitely will be returning. The crust is the perfect crispy yet soft thin crust that you can easily cut with a fork. The cheese was greasy and had a very nice oven toasted top that I rarely find. Not too much sauce and even reheated very well. I'm not a pizza snob but I don't want to give 5 stars only having been there once. I'll have to try a specialty pizza and something else and I'll let you know if this is a 5 star worthy joint.
(4)Dan S.
Excellent service and great food. The staff is warm and friendly. On my way out the door I dropped my food on the floor and no questions asked, the cook came over, picked it up, and replaced it at no cost. Good people work here and the pizza is delicious!
(5)Kevin S.
Love the Ybor store, live in Wesley Chapel, gave them a try tonight...amazing! So glad they have one closer to home, great pizza!!
(5)Bruce G.
Tried the Ybor New York New York many times. Defiantly the best delivery pizza in wesley chapel...
(5)Stephanie P.
Delicious New York Style pizza! Also their cheese steaks are incredible too!
(5)Gail L.
Had to try the new place in town. Clean dining room and pleasant staff. Pizza was good but not great. Crust was a bit soggy but I think that is our fault for ordering double mushrooms. We will be back to try their many menu options but I think we will stick with Marcos when it is time for pizza.
(3)Will W.
The newest pizza place in town. So very worth the visit. Everything we have tried on the menu is fantastic. Hand made items made to order in authentic NY style perfection. If you find yourself in lovely, sunny Wesley Chapel but crave the tase from the NYC beat feet to NY NY Pizza!
(5)